Ned Grabavoy (Photo: Rob Gray)
Chris Wingert (Photo: Rob Gray)
New York took Ned with the second pick
New York took Chris with the 20th and final pick
The rest of the picks for the Expansion Draft
| ROUND | ORLANDO CITY SC | NEW YORK CITY FC |
| 1 | GK Donovan Ricketts (POR) | MF Ned Grabavoy (RSL) |
| 2 | MF Tony Cascio (COL) | FW Patrick Mullins (NE) |
| 3 | DF Jalil Anibaba (SEA) | DF Jason Hernandez (SJ) |
| 4 | MF/FW Pedro Ribeiro (PHI) | MF Daniel Lovitz (TOR) |
| 5 | MF Lewis Neal (DC) | FW Tony Taylor (NE) |
| 6 | FW Jairo Arrieta (CLB) | MF Mehdi Ballouchy (VAN) |
| 7 | DF Heath Pearce (MTL) | DF George John (DAL) |
| 8 | FW Danny Mwanga (COL) | MF Thomas McNamara (DC) |
| 9 | FW Mark Sherrod (HOU) | MF Sal Zizzo (SKC) |
| 10 | DF Eric Gehrig (CLB) | DF Chris Wingert (RSL) |